Ah, the Super Bowl. The one day of the year when grown men paint their faces, consume an ungodly amount of chicken wings, and either celebrate or mourn as if their own life depended on the outcome of a football game. It’s a day of high emotions, dramatic plays, and—for those of us striving to be Catholic men of virtue—an opportunity to reflect on something deeper.
Because here’s the thing: as Catholic men, we don’t just passively consume culture—we engage with it. We find meaning in it. We use it to grow in our faith, to set an example for our families, and to seek out ways to glorify God in everything we do.
And that includes deciding who to root for in Super Bowl LIX.
Now, I’ll be upfront about something. This is painful for me to write. Why? Because my beloved 49ers were, once again, sent packing by the Kansas City Chiefs. TWICE. If you think that doesn’t sting, you’re mistaken. But as much as it pains me, I’m willing to set aside my personal grievances for the greater good. So, let’s huddle up and break down which team deserves the support of Catholic men striving for virtue.
The Intersection of Faith and Football
Football is more than just a game. It’s a test of discipline, perseverance, teamwork, and courage—all virtues that align with our Catholic faith. Many players rely on their relationship with God to navigate the pressures of the NFL, and Super Bowl LIX is no exception.
While most people are trying to figure out what Taylor Swift will be wearing to the game, there is plenty of virtue to be had with sports. Discipline equals freedom as Jocko Willink loves to say. To get to the pinnacle of the NFL's greatest prize, you must be disciplines. As men strive towards the goal of the ultimate prize in football today, let us take it as a lesson in the spiritual life. We need brothers with us. Without each other, we cannot reach the ultimate prize: heaven.
Both the Kansas City Chiefs and the Philadelphia Eagles have strong Christian influences on their rosters, making this a tough call. But let’s break it down.
Faith Profiles of Key Players
Kansas City Chiefs
-
Harrison Butker (Kicker): If you’re looking for a player who walks the walk as a devout Catholic, look no further than Butker. He’s outspoken about his faith, unafraid to stand up for traditional Catholic values, and even encourages young men to embrace their vocations as husbands and fathers. He’s also a regular at the Traditional Latin Mass—how’s that for a kicker? citeturn0search4
-
Patrick Mahomes (Quarterback): The face of the NFL, Mahomes frequently credits God for his success. After clinching another Super Bowl appearance, he said, "I want to give all glory to God. Without Him, none of this is possible." A leader on the field and a man of faith? Not bad.
Philadelphia Eagles
-
Jalen Hurts (Quarterback): Hurts wears his faith on his sleeve—literally. He’s known for saying, "God is greater than any high or low," showing that his trust in the Lord remains steadfast no matter the situation.
-
Saquon Barkley (Running Back): New to the Eagles, Barkley has been open about wanting to deepen his relationship with Christ, showing that faith isn’t just about where you are, but where you’re going.
The Deciding Factor: Harrison Butker’s Bold Witness
Look, both teams have solid Christian men. But if we’re basing our decision on who has been the most outspoken, unapologetic witness for Catholicism, the answer is clear: Harrison Butker and the Kansas City Chiefs.
This is a guy who has used his platform to defend the truths of the faith, encourage strong marriages, and call men to live out their God-given vocations. He’s not just praying before games—he’s calling out society’s attacks on masculinity, family, and virtue. The man even wears a brown scapular and displays it through his uniform.
Even though it pains me as a 49ers fan to say this… the Chiefs are the Catholic pick this year.
Enjoy the Game, Stay Virtuous
At the end of the day, the Super Bowl is meant to be fun. Enjoy the game, spend time with family, and keep things in perspective—football is great, but eternity is greater.
And if the Chiefs win? Well, at least we know we backed the team with a kicker who knows the true prize isn’t a Super Bowl ring—it’s heaven.
Join the Fight for Catholic Manhood
At The Manly Catholic, we challenge, encourage, and motivate men to step up, grow in holiness, and become saints. Whether it’s tackling spiritual warfare, diving into the lives of the saints, or discussing the tough battles Catholic men face today, we’ve got you covered.
Join us, because the real fight isn’t on the football field—it’s for our souls.
